- Three faults, three places to look
- Reading the olive drift
- Reading the red edge
- Reading a mottled tin
- Four checks with no equipment
- What can go wrong when making green tea?
- Why did my green tea turn olive?
- What does a red edge on the leaf mean?
- Why does my tea taste different between pours?
- How can I check the moisture?
Kill-green fails in three ways and each one leaves a signature a buyer can read. Under-fixed leaf keeps its enzymes and turns olive in the tin within months. Over-fixed leaf scorches at the edge and turns that edge red. Uneven fixing leaves some leaf green and some yellow in the same tin. The three are worth separating because only one of them is partly recoverable and because each appears at a different moment.
The olive drift shows after storage, the red edge shows on the dry leaf and the mottling shows in the cup. Each fault also appears at a different moment in the tea’s life. A buyer who knows all three can reject a tin in a shop. A fault at the fixation stage is worth recognising because it is the only stage where a mistake cannot be undone later. Rolling can be lightened, drying can be extended, and sorting can remove a fraction, but a leaf that was heated too little or too much has already committed. The three faults below are the ones a buyer will meet.
Three faults, three places to look
| Fault | Cause | Sign in the leaf | Sign in the cup | Fixable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under-fixed | Leaf under 75 °C internally | Olive after 2 months | Grassy, then sour | No |
| Over-fixed | Above 340 °C at the surface | Red or brown edge | Burnt at the front | No |
| Uneven | Too much leaf in the drum | Green and yellow pieces | Changes between pours | Partly |
| Over-rolled | 20 minutes plus | Dust at the tin bottom | Bitter at 60 seconds | No |
| Damp finish | 8 per cent moisture | Leaf bends | Stale in 6 months | Partly |
Under-fixing is the fault a buyer meets most and the one that looks like a storage problem. The leaf leaves the factory a normal green and turns olive over two to three months as the enzymes finish the work they should never have started. The change is gradual and easy to blame on the tin. Over-firing announces itself on the shelf rather than in the cup, which is what makes it the easiest fault to refuse.
The margin of the leaf is thinnest and discolours first, so a red rim against a green centre means the drum ran hot for part of the batch. A buyer can see it at arm length and needs no sample. Over-rolling belongs to the stage after fixation and it shows in the cup within a minute. Excess pressure cracks the cell walls of much of the leaf, and a batch with forty per cent broken cells gives up its content almost at once. The first infusion is heavy and the second is nearly empty, which is a pattern no fixation fault produces.
Reading the olive drift
| Months after packing | Colour | Aroma | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month 0 | Bright green | Fresh, chestnut | Sound |
| Month 2 | Slightly duller | A little flatter | Possibly under-fixed |
| Month 5 | Olive | Hay, no chestnut | Under-fixed |
| Month 12 | Brown-green | Stale, papery | Under-fixed and old |
The olive drift is the slowest signal and the only one that needs the calendar rather than the senses. A well-fixed leaf keeps its green for a year in a sealed tin, while an under-fixed one turns olive inside a season and the change cannot be reversed by storage. Waiting three months is the only test that separates it from a sound batch.
The cup confirms it and the direction is diagnostic. An under-fixed leaf opens grassy and turns sour by the third infusion, because the products of continued oxidation are sour rather than bitter. A properly fixed leaf opens with chestnut and stays sweet. Sourness at the third pour is the signature. Chestnut turning to hay is the same signal. There is no repair and that is worth stating plainly. Re-drying an under-fixed leaf does not reverse the oxidation that already happened and does not restore the colour. The only remedy is at the drum, and the fault is decided before the tin is packed. The fault is set before the tin is packed.
Reading the red edge
The size of the red margin reports how far over the temperature went. A thin brown line at the very edge means a brief overshoot, while a broad red band covering a third of the leaf means the drum was running hot for the whole batch. The second is not drinkable at any price. A broad band is not drinkable at any price.
The cup confirms it at the front of the mouth. A scorched leaf gives a burnt note immediately and then nothing, because the sugars that would have given sweetness were destroyed. That empty middle is the difference between over-fired and merely strong. Sweetness is what went missing. Over-firing is not recoverable and it is not hidden by blending. A small proportion of scorched leaf in a blend is detectable in the cup and it drags the whole tin down. That is why a producer sorts it out rather than mixing it in.
Reading a mottled tin
| Appearance | Cause | Cup behaviour | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Even bright green | Sound fixation | Consistent across pours | Yes |
| Green and yellow mixed | Drum overfilled | Changes between pours | Only if cheap |
| Green with olive patches | Partial fixing | Grassy then sour | No |
| Even olive | Under-fixed throughout | Flat and grassy | No |
The mottled tin is the fault of a drum that held too much leaf and it is the easiest to spot. Leaf against the hot wall fixes faster than leaf in the middle, so the batch comes out in two colours. That is a mechanical fault rather than a chemical one and it looks different from the olive drift.
The cup behaviour is what separates mottling from under-fixing. A mottled tin changes between pours because the two fractions extract at different rates, while an evenly under-fixed tin is consistently grassy. The first varies and the second does not. One varies and the other does not. The rate of extraction gives it away. Mottling is partly recoverable by sorting, which is why it is the only item on the list with a qualification. A producer who sieves and sorts can remove the under-fixed fraction of perhaps 2 kg from a 20 kg batch and sell the rest at a lower grade.
A buyer cannot do that at home, which is why the fault is a discount rather than a rejection. The practical consequence is that a mottled tin should be cheap. It is not a fraud and it is a batch that was run too fast through an overloaded drum.
At a third of the price it is drinkable and at full price it is a poor buy.
Four checks with no equipment
The dry leaf colour is the first check and it takes ten seconds. Bright even green is sound, a red or brown edge is over-fired, and a mixture of green and yellow is mottled. Those three cover most of what a shop will hold, and none of them needs a cup, a scale or any training at all.
The thumb test is the second and it catches the damp finish. A properly finished leaf, somewhere between four and six per cent moisture, crushes to fragments with a dry snap, while one at 8 per cent bends between the fingers. The second will go stale within six months whatever else is right with it. It is the only moisture check a buyer has. The cup is the third and it separates the faults that look alike. A grassy first pour that turns sour is under-fixed, a burnt front with an empty middle is over-fired, and a cup that changes between pours is mottled.
Three directions, three faults, and each has its own direction across three pours. The last check is the powder that settles in the tin, and a layer deeper than 2 mm reports the rolling rather than the fixation, which reports the rolling rather than the fixation.
A tin with a visible layer of dust was over-rolled and will give a bitter first infusion within a minute. That is a fault of the stage after fixation and it is worth checking separately.
- Three fixation faults: under-fixed turns olive in the tin, over-fixed turns red at the leaf edge, and uneven fixing mottles the batch.
- Under-fixing shows after two to five months, which is why it is mistaken for a storage problem.
- A red margin covering a third of the leaf means the drum ran hot for the whole batch.
- Mottling is partly recoverable by sorting and the tin should be cheap.
- A leaf at 4 to 6 per cent snaps between the fingers; at 8 per cent it bends and goes stale.
The processing behind it is described in green tea processing styles and green tea processing steps.
What can go wrong when making green tea?
Under-fixing, over-fixing and uneven fixing, plus over-rolling and a damp finish. Only uneven fixing and a damp finish are partly recoverable.
Why did my green tea turn olive?
It was under-fixed, so the enzymes kept working in the tin. The change takes two to five months and cannot be reversed.
What does a red edge on the leaf mean?
The drum ran above 340 °C at the surface and scorched the thin margin. The cup will have a burnt front and an empty middle.
Why does my tea taste different between pours?
The batch was mottled, usually from an overloaded drum. Two fractions extract at different rates.
How can I check the moisture?
Crush a leaf. At 4 to 6 per cent it snaps into fragments; at 8 per cent it bends and will go stale within six months.
